A former Canadian Football League wide receiver who viciously beat his ex-girlfriend, choked her to death, then staged the scene to make it look like an accident, should be sentenced to life in prison without a chance of parole for at least 15 years, a Crown prosecutor says.
Brendan McCabe told BC Supreme Court that Joshua Boden tossed pills around Kimberly Hallgarth’s body, put some in her mouth and then stuffed it with socks as she lay dying at the bottom of the stairs at her home in Burnaby.
“We don’t even know how Ms. Hallgarth ended up at the bottom of the stairs,” McCabe said at the sentencing hearing Thursday.
GRAPHIC WARNING: The following details may be disturbing for some readers.
McCabe said Boden stomped on the woman’s neck and chest while she was unconscious, tore out her fingernails, moved her body and wiped it with a towel before removing two garbage bags, which he suggested contained items related to the crime.
He called the murder “blunt, brutal and horrific” and said photos of the injuries endured by a vulnerable woman were the most shocking he’d seen in his career and had been inflicted by a “large, powerful man” who has not shown remorse .
Boden, 35, was found guilty last fall of second-degree murder in the 2009 death of 33-year-old Hallgarth in the home the court heard was a sanctuary she shared with her three-year-old daughter.
Boden walked into court Thursday dressed in a dark suit and stared directly at Hallgarth’s family in the gallery before taking a seat in the prisoner’s box, where he flipped through some documents.
McCabe said Hallgarth sent photos of her injuries from a previous assault and damage to her car to then Lions coach Wally Buono, and Boden blamed her for ending his football career.
He said that while Boden maintains the racism he experienced as a Black person growing up in North Vancouver should be considered as a contributing factor at sentencing, there was no link to the crime.
McCabe presented a report from a psychologist showing Boden said he and his brother were the only two Black students at their school but that he was popular among his friends.
This would be the second time race and culture have been cited as factors at a sentencing hearing in British Columbia, he said. The judge in the first case did not accept it, he added.
A second-degree murder conviction carries a life sentence of 25 years but parole eligibility can be set starting at 10 years.
Kevin Westell, Boden’s defense lawyer, asked that he serve 12 years before being eligible.
Boden’s experience of systemic racism, poor role modeling from his parents, sexual abuse by an older woman, along with his ADHD and dyslexia put him at a disadvantage, Westell said.
“There’s not a direct link, but there’s an indirect link,” he said of the murder. “It’s not meant to excuse or condone the offense that was committed.”
While McCabe said Boden had been “pimping out” the mother of his two sons since she was 16, Westell said the woman had said in a statement that sex work was her choice. Westell said Boden also did sex work for income.
He was described by his children’s mother as a “good father”, Westell said, and his current girlfriend and brother would support him whenever he is released from prison.
Hallgarth’s family has described her as a bubbly and caring person who deeply loved being a mother to her daughter Hailey.
Vida Miller, Hallgarth’s former mother-in-law, told the court in a victim impact statement that she is caring for her granddaughter outside of BC, and that the now teenager’s life has forever been impacted by the torture her mother endured before she died.
She said Hailey returned home with her nanny the day her mother was killed but the woman could not open the door because Hallgarth’s body was blocking it.
The discovery of Hallgarth’s body had the nanny “screaming and crying in terror,” Miller told court over video link.
“Knock on the door, Nanna, knock on the door,” is what the little girl insisted at the time, she said, adding Hailey still can’t sleep without the lights on.
Hailey told court she would do anything just to have a conversation with her mother.
“He took the world from me,” she said via the video link. “He took a piece of my life that I can never get back.”
Justice Arne Silverman told them both that their words were important for the public to know.
“I promise you that I’ll keep in mind what you read to me,” he said. “I’ll never forget it.”
Boden played for the BC Lions in 2007 but was released by the team in 2008 and signed with the Hamilton Tiger-Cats, although he never played a regular-season game with that team before he was cut.
He waived his right to address the court on Thursday and has maintained his innocence.
The sentencing hearing is set to resume on June 24, when Silverman is expected to announce his decision on parole eligibility.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 16, 2021.